RASHTRA BHAW

"प्रेम भी प्रतिशोध भी"

68 Posts

1377 comments

Reader Blogs are not moderated, Jagran is not responsible for the views, opinions and content posted by the readers.
blogid : 5095 postid : 180

Just An Age Dispute Or Conspiracy Against Army?

Posted On: 23 Jan, 2012 पॉलिटिकल एक्सप्रेस में

  • SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

vkSINGH-screen1Indian Army has been renowned for its powerful as well as undisputed history. Its first time when the army and the government are not only in a confrontational mood but the dispute of Army Chief’s age is likely to knock the doors of Supreme Court. Many commentators are interpreting it as a hole in army’s image but honestly this is stain of government’s tail. According to General V.K Singh, his actual date of birth according to his 10th and 12th certificates is May 10, 1951 which, by a clerical mistake, was written in his UPSC admit card as May 10, 1950. If his DOB is considered as May 1950 he’ll have to be retired on May 31, 2012 otherwise he would enjoy the post until March, 2013. General Singh simply requested the Defense Ministry to consider his real DOB instead of the false one but why did government initially kept the issue hanging and later turned recalcitrant giving a space for controversy, only government can answer it.
army chief dobThis is of common sense that any DOB related issue in a job is dealt considering only the minimum required education certificates therefore if government accepts the application of the General Singh nothing would be illegitimate but the government seems technically entangling the issue unnecessarily. Probably this would be the first case of its own type where the government is insisting to consider an error as proof over the certificates. The saying from the government, unnecessarily stubborn to create a controversy, that the General Singh’s move to SC is unfortunate is only reflecting the shameless importunity that he should accept any inconsistent decision of govt. On the one hand, govt. is trying to hit General Singh for his move to SC while on the other hand it, without any hesitance, is saying that the case will be resolved now only within the court.
It’s also a matter of surprise that the legal advice of attorney general to defense ministry which gave the ground to reject the general’s plea also looks ridiculous and stereotyped. Attorney general G.E Vahanvati argues that the High School or Inter marks sheets can’t be sole basis for considering the DOB at this stage. However, how can one justify this amazing argument that one’s education certificates, which were the eligibility proof while recruitment, have become outdated for an issue during the same job? Furthermore, govt. wants to consider General Singh’s erroneous UPSC form, which is in fact few months older than his 12th certificate, as basis of his DOB. Imagine if General Singh’s DOB in UPSC form, at that time, was fulfilling the eligibility criteria but his educational certificates couldn’t match with DOB written in form! Could he be selected for the job? Or did he not get booked under the case of forgery?
The govt is consistently coming up with nonsense arguments in spite of the fact that UPSC itself corrected the mistake later. The second argument of the govt states that General Singh has already accepted his DOB as May 1950 while his recruitment as the Army Chief and now he is betraying by demanding reconsideration in his DOB. The fact is that General Singh never accepted his inaccurate DOB, he only wrote to the then Army Chief Gen Deepak Kapoor that he believed in his leadership and was ready to obey him, in spite of his distinct thoughts. Another question may be asked that if govt wants to say that the Gen Singh was appointed as per deal or agreement? It’s also interesting that the advice by an Attorney General of a country is rebutted by four Ex-CJs and a solicitor general terming it as feeble. All four Ex-CJIs including G.B Patnaik and J.S Verma and Ex-solicitor general Gopal Subramaniam supported the Army Chief’s claim legally.
The Question is why did our govt. get stuck on such simple but sensitive issue? It’s clear from sources that there are few inside the army who were honestly sacked by Gen Singh in Sukna land scam and Adarsh Society scam. But the conspiracy against the Gen Singh might be initiated by such tainted officers, why govt is so tough and rude towards the Gen Singh? Does leaders, inside the govt, also have problem with an honest and dedicated Army Chief? Adarsh Society scam has been a big headache for the govt recently therefore all questions requires honest investigation in this direction.
Our media also didn’t show sufficient due patience, minding the image of our army on global platform, during the whole up and down. Some so called advocates of free speech tried to slam the Gen Singh directly. According to them, consulting former CJIs and telling his side to some persons Gen Singh committed disobedience of the democratic govt which is against the democracy and the people of India. But probably the commentators forget that an army-man takes oath of truth and serving his country not of obeying leaders blindly. Gen Manekshaw also denied following the order of then PM Indira Gandhi in 1971 war. Gen Singh has also cleared that he wanted the change in DOB only to protect his integrity, the decision on tenure is government’s right. One can’t expect a bigger sophism than saying that the Gen Singh’s move is against the people of India, everybody knows people of India always have greater belief and respect for our Army rather than in our political system, in this controversy too. Unfortunately those who are trying to teach lessons of duty to an honest and diligent army officer, have been advocating against the integrity of Kashmir from the stages of exposed ISI agent Gulam Navi Fai.
Army is clean and strongest pillar of India’s sovereignty and integrity, it would be better to keep it apart from the selfish political conspiracies and evil sights for which the govt. would have to be honest and enough sensitive towards this pillar of democracy.

Rate this Article:

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (5 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

22 प्रतिक्रिया

  • SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Post a Comment

CAPTCHA Image
*

Reset

नवीनतम प्रतिक्रियाएंLatest Comments

Chicago SEO के द्वारा
July 11, 2014

Recently, the entire world hasbeen experiencing quick, considerable, and old modifications in the technique companies industry and also how individuals look themselves. Just a few small years back, internet sites and marketing were an overinflated fad down-enjoyed by entrepreneurs and numerous organizations. Not so nowadays. The previous few years have seen the emergence of countless efficient and realistic instruments for organizations to make use of to greatly help them expand business and income. Quite the “next big thing” is occurring as firms are progressively centering their promoting and SEO attempts on websites that are cell. Having 52PERCENT of the American adults owning a smart-phone, businesses have seen excellent possibility of elevated revenue by building cell SEO. Using the total mobile offer earnings forecast for 2014 being fully a astonishing DOLLAR3.5B, 25 of the National makes possess a strategy that is cellular, in fact, eight times what it had been in 2009.

Chicago SEO के द्वारा
July 10, 2014

Lately, the planet has been experiencing quickly, considerable, and traditional improvements in the way firms industry and also how people look themselves. Just a few years that are short back, online businesses and advertising were an overinflated craze down-performed by numerous organizations and marketers. Not so nowadays. The last few decades have seen countless realistic and effective tools for businesses’ beginning to work with to simply help income and enterprise grows. Really the “nextbigthing” is transpiring as corporations are significantly focusing their marketing and SEO work on sites that are mobile. By creating mobile SEO with 52 of the National adults running a smart-phone, firms have observed excellent possibility of increased sales. With the whole cell ad income prediction regarding 2014 being truly a astonishing DOLLAR3.5B, 25PERCENT of the National manufacturers have a cellular method, in fact, seven occasions what it was in ‘09.

Chicago SEO के द्वारा
July 8, 2014

Currently, the entire world hasbeen experiencing rapidly, significant, and historical alterations in the way individuals store and also the technique businesses market themselves. Just a couple of years that are brief back, internet sites and promoting were an overinflated fad down-enjoyed by numerous businesses and entrepreneurs. Not-so nowadays. The previous couple of decades have experienced the breakthrough of numerous realistic and reliable methods for companies to make use of to simply help enterprise and income grows. Very the “nextbigthing” is currently occurring as firms are significantly focusing their promoting and SEO initiatives on cell websites. Using 52 of the American people owning a smart-phone, corporations have seen fantastic potential for enhanced income by creating portable SEO. Using the total cellular offer earnings estimate for 2014 being truly a staggering DOLLAR3.5B, 25 of the Us manufacturers possess a cellular tactic, in fact, seven times what it was in ‘09.

chicago web design के द्वारा
July 7, 2014

If you’re still on the fence: grab your favorite earphones, head down to a Best Buy and ask to plug them into a Zune then an iPod and see which one sounds better to you, and which interface makes you smile more. Then you’ll know which is right for you.

free web traffic links bonus #1 के द्वारा
June 30, 2014

check out my campaign online for more info

nancy4vaye के द्वारा
February 25, 2012

नमस्ते प्रिय! मेरा नाम नैन्सी है, मैं अपनी प्रोफ़ाइल को देखा और अगर आप कर रहे हैं आप के साथ संपर्क में प्राप्त करना चाहते मुझ में भी दिलचस्पी तो कृपया मुझे एक संदेश जितनी जल्दी भेजें। (nancy_0×4@hotmail.com) नमस्ते नैन्सी ***************************** Hello Dear! My name is Nancy, I saw your profile and would like to get in touch with you If you’re interested in me too then please send me a message as quickly as possible. (nancy_0×4@hotmail.com) Greetings Nancy

shivendra mohan singh के द्वारा
January 25, 2012

वासुदेव जी हिंदी में भी पोस्ट करो ज्यादा से ज्यादा लोगों तक बात पहुचे…

    vasudev tripathi के द्वारा
    January 25, 2012

    आदरणीय शिवेंद्र जी, मुझे आपके इस सुझाव से हार्दिक प्रसन्नता हुई| निश्चित रूप से अधिकांशतः लोग अंग्रेजी की मानसिक दासता में जी रहे हैं कि उन्हें हिंदी की बात करते भय लगता है कि कहीं वो पिछड़े न समझ लिए जाएँ! व्यक्तिगत रूप से मैं अंग्रेजी की मानसिक दासता का प्रबलतम विरोधी हूँ इस विषय पर मैंने लेख भी लिखा था “हिंदी का लैमार्कवादी विकास”| मेरे अधिकांश लेख हिंदी में ही हैं| अभी मैं ऐसे स्थान पर हूँ जहाँ मुझे अंग्रेजी में ही लिखना पड़ता है, विषय के हिंदी अनुवाद का समय न मिल पाने के कारण कभी-कभी अंग्रेजी में ही डालना पड़ता है| इस लेख को मैंने २१जनवरी को लिखा था किन्तु हिंदी अनुवाद और फिर टाइपिंग का समय जब नहीं निक पाया तब मैंने अंततः २३ को इसे ऐसे ही डाल दिया| …..हार्दिक धन्यवाद||

yogi sarswat के द्वारा
January 25, 2012

I I think this is not a dispute between indian army and the Govt. This is actually a matter to have his own words . Govt.cant take a step to dismiss him because after all , the DOB on the 10th certificate is usually considered the best age proof . Thank you to write a different and knowledgeable article.

    vasudev tripathi के द्वारा
    January 25, 2012

    Yogi ji, The whole issue has taken the form of controversy bcoz of the insistence of govt and the words used by it. This is our view that DOB in 10th 12th certificates as it is quite obvious but if govt is not ready what can anybody do except hoping from SC..!!! Thanks a lot.

viplavimayank के द्वारा
January 24, 2012

Dear Vasudev Bhai, humble vandematram… Present article is an eye-opener piece of information.kudos to you and your writing skills too.unfortunately we live in a country where nobody dare to ask the details of Sonia ji..we live in a country where India means Indira.might is right brother and our constitution gives no rights for defence personnel.

    vasudev tripathi के द्वारा
    January 25, 2012

    Respected viplaw ji, thank u for your kind attention to the issue. Here people dont realize a need to come out from their comfort zone. Their are many things which are not going in smooth way in this democracy. we need consciousness.

nishamittal के द्वारा
January 23, 2012

ur views on this current (unfortunate ) issue are really praiseworthy.politics in this issue is a shame in our democracy.

    vasudev tripathi के द्वारा
    January 25, 2012

    Respected Nisha ji, today our democracy is ashamed on many platforms. This is also one of those but different from others bcoz this is against the honor and image of our army. thanx a lot.

rahulpriyadarshi के द्वारा
January 23, 2012

In fact,the whole secular media…including those inspired by ultra-secular Congress are behind these conspiracies…our soldiers are our biggest assets,any attack over their reputation is an attack over our sovereignty itself,such mean politics should not be tolerated anymore…a very nice article,I welcome ur writings over this issue.

    vasudev tripathi के द्वारा
    January 25, 2012

    Rahul bhai, i agree with you. The reputation of our army is definitely damaging that’s why i asked if its a conspiracy against army? Surely there are people in power who are not worried about it all. I liked your word “ultra-secular” very much. Thanks for thoughtful comment.


topic of the week



latest from jagran